From CNBC, November 19:
- Panmure Liberum’s Joachim Klement said Thursday he planned to sell all of his stocks.
- His team said in a note that investors should “go fully defensive.”
- They outlined why they’re anticipating the AI bubble will soon burst, and which pockets of the market offer “the best hiding place.”
Many investors appear bullish on stocks and the artificial intelligence trade early on Thursday, with Anthropic ’s Nasdaq debut expected to break Wall Street records at market open. But for one seasoned investor, Nov. 19 is the day to cash out of the equity market entirely. “This is it,” Joachim Klement, a research analyst at Panmure Liberum, said in a note on Thursday morning. “Why I am selling.”
Klement confirmed to CNBC that he would be selling all stocks in his personal holdings, not just those listed in the United States. “The S & P 500 has broken below its 200-day moving average, and we are moving into a fully defensive position,” his team wrote in Thursday’s note. “While this indicator is not foolproof, market dynamics have turned decisively bearish, in our view.” Klement, a former chief investment officer who has worked in financial markets for two decades, has been warning of an AI bubble since May. He said he had become even more bearish since the end of the summer. “I have always emphasized that my personal trigger is the S & P 500 relative to the 200-day moving average,” he reiterated in Thursday’s note. “If the S & P 500 drops below the 200D MA, I will sell equities and move into long-term government bonds. If it then moves above the 200D MA again, I will move back into stocks until the S & P 500 drops below the 200D MA.” Klement conceded that this strategy “may incur a lot of portfolio churn,” but said he would be “out of stocks when the AI bubble bursts and back in if setbacks are temporary in nature and not persistent.” “At the end of European trading, I will sell my personal holdings in stocks and move into long-term government bonds,” he said. “I may be wrong, and this is not the bubble bursting, but if that is the case, my trading rule will ensure I go back in without too much opportunity cost.”
Bond markets have also been volatile this year, with debt issued by governments across the globe selling off aggressively as the Iran war fed expectations of inflationary pressure and more hawkish central banks. Klement’s team at Panmure Liberum first warned about the risk of an AI bubble bursting back in May, after they examined the AI capex boom. Panmure Liberum’s analysis suggested a reversal of the boom could lead to a drop in stock markets of 30% or more. In September, the group’s analysts predicted the AI bubble would burst in either 2027 or 2028, pricing the chance of that happening next year at almost 50%. A month later, they increased the likelihood of an AI crash in 2027 and introduced a price target for the S & P 500 of 5,000 points for the end of 2027.
That represents a retreat of 35% from where the index was trading at the time. On Wednesday, the S & P 500 closed at 7,323.63 points. .SPX YTD line S & P 500 “Today, we recommend investors go fully defensive as price momentum has, in our view, decisively shifted to the downside,” Panmure Liberum’s analysts wrote on Thursday. Panmure Liberum has been observing two other triggers to assess whether the AI bubble had run its course: capex by AI hyperscalers and Anthropic’s IPO. “In recent weeks we have seen Microsoft aggressively cull its deals in neoclouds and focus its capex more on self-built data centres,” Klement wrote.
“This is not yet a reduction in capex vs 2027 expectations, but we still think that capex guidance for 2027 could be lower than current expectations. And every dollar less in capex vs expectations means one dollar less in revenues for the semiconductor supply chain.” His team added in the note that it’s “clear” from Anthropic’s regulatory filings that “revenue growth is slowing down both relative to compute costs and, more importantly, in absolute terms.”....
....MUCH MORE
Our first mention of Mr. Klement on the blog was on May Day, 2015 when he was working in Zurich.
Since then we've linked to him either at Reuters where he wears a columnist hat or at his personal substack.
April 2021 - Follow-up: Inside The Secretive World Of Chinese Foreign Infrastructure Loans
September 2024 -"Germans are bad at investing"
February 2026 - "Why investors are getting the US debasement trade all wrong"
A Reuters mini-essay from Joachim Klement whose substack tagline is:
Thoughts
on financial markets by a grumpy, middle-aged German. What more do you
want? Click to read Klement on Investing, by Joachim Klement, a Substack
publication with tens of thousands of subscribers.
And on IPOs marking a top:
February 2026 - "OpenAI, SpaceX and other IPOs could break the S&P 500, Jeremy Grantham says"
Ummm, yes.*
———
*Subjects near and dear: supply, demand, liquidity etc.
October 2008 - IPOs Produce Smallest Gains Since 1995 as Offerings Increase
Supply and demand. The one effect I can guarantee is the sopping up of
billions of dollars and yuan* that would otherwise go into currently
trading issues. IPO exits are not only a sign of a top but actually help
bring them on by removing some liquidity....
December 2018 - "Nasdaq, 'Tech,' & IPOs are in for Gut-Wrencher"
The Fed's interest rate moves are not that big a deal.
I know that runs counter to a lot of commentary but the upticks are not a problem. Yet.
The bigger headwind facing the market is the Fed's balance sheet unwind sucking up liquidity.
And next year's planned mega-IPOs threatening to do the same....
September 2025 - "US IPO Activity On Track For Best Quarter Since Q1 2022"
This is what we were referring to introducing August 6's "Blackstone prepares portfolio companies for IPOs":
One of the reasons markets trend higher is a lack of new shares coming on to the market.
Over
the last few months the IPO window has been opening and the offerings
absorb buying power that would otherwise go into issues already trading.
See also: supply/demand.
The Wall Street marketeers are nothing if not opportunistic.
And
depending on how much stuff they are primping, packaging, and pushing,
this is why stock offerings tend to mark the short/intermediate-term
tops in markets.
Just something to be aware of, not a hard and fast rule.
Regarding Mr. Grantham, though he is historically early—keeping in mind that if you are too early, you're not early, you're wrong, I think he is right about the market direction later this year, if not the exact trigger we will point back to.
Anyhoo, we've been keeping track of the G-man's prognostications for a very long time. Here's the outro from a December 2022 post:
....Grantham's problem, shared by moi, is that just
because one sees an anomaly, there really isn't any reason to think the
market will act on it in the time frame that you think it might.
May 2026 - "Elon Musk’s SpaceX accelerates timeline for blockbuster Nasdaq IPO"
That giant sucking sound? It's liquidity leaving currently tradable stocks to fund this season's IPOs.*
June 2026 - Deutsche Bank: "Will the IPO wave derail equities?"
June 2026 - Who Will Buy These Giant IPOs After They Begin Trading? You Will (SpaceX; OpenAI; Anthropic et al.)
Or, more accurately, the index funds in your retirement account will.