From the BlackRock Investment Institute, April 7:
Global economic activity is not simply contracting. It is being
deliberately frozen and halted. Doing this at the global level is
unprecedented. The near-term blow to growth is likely to be severe. We
believe that the U.S. activity shortfall – the sum of activity lost
every quarter relative to its pre-shock 2019 trend – is likely to be
more than twice as large as the global financial crisis (GFC) shock over
a three-quarter timeframe. Yet the implications for asset prices depend
on the cumulative impact over time. We believe that with the
appropriate policy response and execution, the overall impact of the
ongoing coronavirus shock will be far less extreme than the one seen
during the financial crisis.
Overview
The risk asset reaction to the coronavirus shock has so far been of
an order of magnitude similar to the financial crisis. The important
question for judging of the market reaction is not whether this will be a
V-, U- or L-shaped recession, but whether the overall macro impact will
itself be of an order of magnitude similar to the financial crisis.
There has just never been such a systematic attempt to shut down
activity on such a scale before. Making sense of the macro implications
here is not an exercise in minutiae. What we need is to understand the
order of magnitudes involved – distinguishing between the impact being
“5x” and not just “x”, both on the downside and upside. This starts by
distinguishing between the 1) shock and its 2) propagation. Both are
very different from the GFC. The GFC’s macro damage was mostly wrought
by its spread through debt deleveraging and the slow unwind of
imbalances over several years. We see the 2020 damage stemming primarily
from the shock itself.
A significant shock
Hypothetical hit to U.S. GDP in coming years compared with the global financial crisis, 2020
In 2008, the shock’s spark was in the financial system and the
impact on real activity was indirect and more uncertain. The main growth
consequence of the GFC was not the shock itself – the recession – but
the propagation: a major decline in activity relative to its pre-shock
trend caused by large-scale debt deleveraging and the unwind of
imbalances over many years. The cumulative post-GFC growth shortfall in
the U.S. totalled about 50% of pre-crisis GDP level – and most of it
came well after the initial shock. See the chart above on the left. If
we accounted for the permanent downshift to potential growth, the
shortfall would be on a different scale altogether....
....
MUCH MORE