America's Engineering Hubs: Silicon Valley, Houston, Wichita
From Joel Kotkin:
America has always been a nation of tinkerers. Our Founding Fathers, notes author Alec Foege,
were innovators in areas ranging from agriculture (George Washington,
Thomas Jefferson) and electricity (Benjamin Franklin) to the swivel
chair (Jefferson).
Engineering advances drove America’s quest for industrial supremacy
in the 19th century, many of them borrowed (sometimes illegally) from
the then very resourceful British Isles. By the early 19th century, the
U.S. was producing its own major inventions, including the steamboat and
cotton gin. By the end of that century, the U.S. was clearly on the way
to industrial preeminence. The growth of engineering schools — MIT, the
Case Institute, Stevens Institute of Technology, as well as departments
at the great land grant universities — generated a steady supply of
engineers. For much of the last 70 years, America, has been the world’s
leading center of engineering excellence, dominating markets from steel
and cars to energy and aerospace.
Today, as well, where engineers concentrate, we can expect the
greatest capacity for innovation. According to research from Houston
Partnership economist Patrick Jankowski, there is a wide range of
concentrations of engineering talent among the country’s 85 largest
metropolitan areas. For the most part, regions with higher
concentrations of engineers tend to do better, and seize the leadership
of key industries.
Nowhere is this more true than in America’s top engineering hub, San
Jose/Silicon Valley. The Valley’s ratio of 45 engineers per 1,000
employees is twice as high as any other big metro area. This deep
reservoir of talent remains the Valley’s key asset, and has made it by
most measurements the nation’s most affluent metro area.
This preeminence dates to the Valley’s early history, particularly in
research sponsored by the Defense Department and NASA. This large
high-tech workforce was then backed by venture capitalists, many of them
also engineers by training, to form by far the most dominant high-tech
region in the world. The presence of Stanford, now rated the nation’s second leading engineering school by U.S. News & World Report after MIT, Berkeley, ranked third and Santa Clara, at No. 14, gives the area an unmatched capacity to produce technologists.
More surprising, perhaps, is the second city on our list: Houston.
The world energy capital is home to 59,000 engineers — second most in
the U.S. after the much larger Los Angeles metro area — and has a
concentration of 22.4 engineers per 1,000 employees. Although it does
not match the Bay Area in elite engineering schools, Houston is home to
Rice University and the University of Houston, both highly regarded,
and, perhaps equally important, a strong sub-structure of trade and technical schools that feed into the engineering pool.
Key here is the energy industry, which is far more
technology-dependent than many might believe. Houston is arguably now
the country’s most important emerging city, with the largest job growth of any major metro area. Not only can engineers make money there, unlike in Silicon Valley, they can also afford to buy a house.
More surprising still is the metro area with the third-highest
concentration of engineers: Wichita, Kan., with 21 engineers per
thousand employees. In this case, the driver is manufacturing,
particularly aerospace. But recent cuts by Boeing threaten the future of
the self-proclaimed “air capital of the world.” As a result, Wichita
has not done nearly as well economically of late as San Jose or Houston,
but its reservoir of engineering talent suggests considerable potential
if they stick around.
These top three engineering cities tell us much about the source of
American innovation, and the remarkable diversity that makes this
country an engineering powerhouse. It involves three essential
industries — information technology, energy and manufacturing. Each has a
distinct geographic makeup that reflects differing kinds of engineering
talent.
The High-Tech Centers
No place comes close to Silicon Valley in terms of concentrations of
engineers, but several other traditional tech centers make the top 10,
led by San Diego in fifth place, a major center for biotech. Boston, home to No. 1 engineering school MIT, ranks eighth, and Denver, which boasts both a thriving tech and energy sector,
is 10th. Other tech regions that rank in the top 20 include Seattle
(13th), San Francisco (18th) and Austin (19th). None of these areas can
claim even half of Silicon Valley’s per capita engineering base, but
have thrived during the current high-tech boom....MORE