P.E. and hedge funds don't buy or set-up insurance operations because they crave the glamor of the actuary lifestyle.
It's financial engineering and sources of funding baby!
From Knowledge@Wharton, November 16:
New Wharton research examines the growing risk of affiliated investments, which expose PE-owned insurers to greater losses under financial stress.
In their new paper “Buying From the Family: Private Equity-Owned Insurers and Their Affiliated Investments,” Wharton professors Amy Huber, Stefan Huber, and Christina Zhu look at how private equity ownership influences the investment decisions of insurers.
They show that PE-owned insurers are willing to finance harder-to-value affiliated securities at higher prices, which tend to underperform and expose insurers to substantial downside risk under stress.
In the Q&A below, Amy Huber, Stefan Huber, and Zhu dive into this research and what it means for financial regulators and practitioners.
Private equity firms have increasingly moved into both insurance and private credit. What drew your attention to the relationship between these trends, and what does your research help us understand about this relationship?
Amy Huber, Stefan Huber, and Christina Zhu: We’ve been puzzled by the rapid expansion of private credit for some time now. Private funds can be expensive for the general partners (GPs) who run them. Limited partners (LPs) provide most of the capital and typically require an 8% return before GPs can begin earning carried interest. This cost of capital can be justified when investments generate high returns, as in traditional private equity. But returns are less obviously high in credit, where profits come primarily from earning a spread, and where there is less scope to add more leverage over and above the credit that the fund itself is extending.
So how can private credit expand at this scale and remain profitable? One possibility is access to a cheaper and more stable source of financing. This makes it natural for alternative asset managers that operate private credit funds to also acquire or partner with insurance companies. Insurers have long-duration, stable liabilities and are therefore natural investors in private credit, which can be less standardized and less liquid than publicly traded bonds. Integration may also reduce information frictions that would otherwise impede mutually beneficial transactions between asset managers and insurers.
At the same time, however, integration may weaken the arm’s-length discipline that ordinarily governs how insurers invest. Does integration change which assets insurers hold, the prices they pay, or their willingness to continue financing particular investments? And what do those changes imply for policyholders and financial stability? These are the questions we hope our research can help answer.
You find that PE-owned insurers allocate a substantial share of their investments toward securities issued by affiliated businesses that are owned by the same PE firm. Why is this significant, and what does it tell us about how PE ownership shapes the investment behavior of insurers?
Amy Huber, Stefan Huber, and Zhu: The scale of these investments is what first caught our attention. By 2024, structured securities accounted for more than 40% of PE-owned insurers’ new investments, and affiliated businesses issued more than 60% of those structured securities. The insurer is therefore doing more than investing alongside the PE firm’s other businesses. It has become a substantial source of financing for them.
That arrangement could have benefits. An insurer may know more about an affiliated investment than an outside buyer does. But the sum of our findings is hard to explain with information advantages alone. That is, we find that PE-owned insurers pay higher prices for affiliated securities than other investors buying the same security on the same day, and are less willing to impair or sell these investments when arm’s-length valuations fall below cost. Yet these securities subsequently underperform. The concern our findings raise is not simply that insurers invest in private credit. It is that a business originating an investment can also influence a large, long-term buyer of that investment....
....MUCH MORE
Possibly also of interest:
July 2025 - "How the next financial crisis might happen"
...And once again just to make things interesting, in addition to plain vanilla private credit, the PE firms seem very attracted to structured products.