Monday, June 5, 2023

Oh My God, What Are The Ukrainian Generals Doing?

They are ordering their men to attack defense-in-depth without air cover and 1/10th the artillery the troops need.

This is what happens when idiot commanders do such things, from a 2019 post:

....I found myself thinking of Pickett's Charge at the Battle of Gettysburg and a quote from one of the men involved.

Following on the charge of the 1st Minnesota Infantry Regiment on day two of the great battle, a charge which destroyed the regiment as a cohesive unit, suffering the highest casualty rate of any American unit (82%) but which stopped the Confederate advance, the stage was set for Day 3.

General Lee thought one audacious move would win the battle and possibly the war.
He ordered 12,500 of his troops, under General Pickett and two other junior generals, to cross a mile of open field and then storm the slight rise of Cemetery Ridge and the steeper slopes of Cemetery Hill.

The results were the Charge of the Light Brigade writ large. The same ~40% casualty rate but amounting to 5100 of the rebels versus the 270 of the 670 attacking British in the Crimea nine years earlier.
One of the Northern officers said of Lee's soldiers as they were first hit with cannons and then by rifle fire

"They were at once enveloped in a dense cloud of smoke and dust. Arms, heads, blankets, guns and knapsacks were thrown and tossed into the clear air. ... A moan went up from the field, distinctly to be heard amid the storm of battle."
—Lt. Col. Franklin Sawyer, 8th Ohio

About Pickett's Charge, called the high-water mark of the Confederacy—though the term would more accurately describe the prior day's charge by the Northerners—the historian Shelby Foote said:

Gettysburg was the price the South paid for having Lee. The first day's fighting was so encouraging, and on the second day's fighting he came within an inch of doing it. And by that time Longstreet said Lee's blood was up, and Longstreet said when Lee's blood was up there was no stopping him... And that was that mistake he made, the mistake of all mistakes. Pickett's charge was an incredible mistake, and there was scarcely a trained soldier who didn't know it was a mistake at the time, except possibly Pickett himself, who was very happy he had a chance for glory. 
...William Faulkner, in "Intruder in the Dust", said that for every southern boy, it's always within his reach to imagine it being one o'clock on an early July day in 1863, the guns are laid, the troops are lined up, the flags are out of their cases and ready to be unfurled, but it hasn't happened yet. And he can go back in his mind to the time before the war was going to be lost and he can always have that moment for himself. 
-Shelby Foote in Ken Burns' "The Civil War

And yesterday's story via

Former officer Swedish Armed Forces/Air Defence, former defence politician and chief of staff Sweden Democrats. Current political and military analyst.
ANALYSIS UKRAINIAN OFFENSIVE OPERATIONS JUNE 4 June 4th UkrAF scaled up offensive operations on the Southern Front, but the losses are too high for long time success.
Earlier operations were mainly reconnaissance in force with platoon and company sized combat groups. Yesterday the ukrainian forces seemed to be battalion sized combat groups. According to Russian MoD 8 UkrAF battalions was involved in offensive operations SE of Mala Tokmachka (1), at the Vremivka salient (2) and East of Vuhledar towards Velikonovoselovka (3).
The fighting was intense, but on most places ukrainian forces was turned back, mainly by intense russian artillery and air attacks. On some places UkrAF succeeded in capturing a couple of hundred meters. There are two different media stories about the fighting. The ukrainian side is very quiet about both the attacks and eventual losses on their side. Russian sources are much more liberal with information, both in text and videos. IF the russian information is correct, this explains the ukrainian silence, since the ukrainian side seldom concedes major losses on their side and tries to shift attention to other subjects....

....MUCH MORE 

The counteroffensive has begun and it is going to be horrific.