The AI buildout is a bubble.*
And we are still riding the bubble.
From Barron's, September 24:
Nvidia has
the hottest product in the world’s biggest investment boom. Its chips
sit within the heart of data centers that power artificial-intelligence
technologies around the globe.
It’s
a $4 trillion behemoth at the center of both U.S. and China’s tech
policy. CEO Jensen Huang, meanwhile, has spoken about “insane” AI demand
dynamics, a “new industrial revolution,” and the potential of an
“infinite” need for computing power.
So why is it paying for someone to buy its newest chips?
It’s
all about growing the AI ecosystem. But it also raises questions about
how that system seems to increasingly moves money within itself.
Nvidia
entered a $100 billion financing arrangement with OpenAI on Monday that
reportedly will see the ChatGPT creator, which has yet to turn a
profit, cede an equity stake to Nvidia as it builds out its data center
capacity. The tech giant also will supply 10 gigawatts of AI
infrastructure to OpenAI, with the first batch built on its next
generation Vera Rubin platform.
Bank
of America analyst Vivek Arya was bullish on the agreement, estimating
it could generate as much as $500 billion in overall revenue for Nvidia.
“Perhaps more importantly, OpenAI will work with Nvidia as a preferred strategic compute and networking partner,” he added.
But
setting aside the need to offer vendor financing to OpenAI, a company
worth an estimated $500 billion—with the backing of Microsoft and the
stamp of approval from the White House—the deal also highlights the
increasing “closed loop” aspect of AI investments.
BofA’s
Arya sees the OpenAI deal as a way for Nvidia to leverage its
impressive profit and free cash flow margins into a flywheel of future
growth.
Regulations
have made direct stakes in other companies more cumbersome, he said.
That means the alternative is to invest in the ecosystem itself in order
to “expand the size of the addressable opportunity that could multiply
future benefits, or accelerate time to market for new products.”
That certainly seems to be the playbook.
Earlier
this month it was reported by The Wall Street Journal that Oracle—one
of Nvidia’s biggest customers— booked a $300 billion contract to provide
computing power to OpenAI, which now, according to reports, has
committed to buying Nvidia chips.
That
leaves billions of dollars flowing from OpenAI into Oracle, then back
into Nvidia, then back into OpenAI, and then back into Nvidia once
again.
But it doesn’t
echo the bullish AI theme of insatiable demand. Nor does it speak well
of Nvidia’s sales concentration, which was exposed in a Securities and
Exchange Commission filing last month.
Two
customers, dubbed “A” and “B” accounted for nearly 40% of Nvidia’s July
quarter revenue, up from around 25% over the same period in 2024.
Adding
OpenAI to the mix alleviates a portion of that concern but seemingly at
an upfront cost. The first $10 billion of the deal will be paid in
cash, in return for a reported equity stake.
The rest of the deal feels a little too dramatic to be true....
....MUCH MORE
The story includes the first mention of possible NVDA revenue of $1 Trillion that we've seen.
Recently:
*And on AI as bubble:
July 2025 - "Microsoft and Meta’s earnings are making every part of the AI supply chain surge" (Ride the Bubble) MSFT; META; NVDA
As reiterated in January 7 2025's:
"Everything (retail) Nvidia Announced at CES 2025"
Reminder: We believe AI is a bubble and have made the decision to ride the bubble.
June 18, 2024: Nvidia's Financial Dominance (NVDA)
For the last year we have been referring to the AI phenomena as a
bubble, perhaps not so much in financial terms but rather in terms of
the psychology, the speculative frenzy. It's true in Nvidia's case, the
stock could be cut in half and still be discounting the future with a
2-3% discount factor i.e. 33 to 50 times free cash flow.
However!
Despite this we have been pitching a "Ride the Bubble" approach to the
stock for over a year (we have an almost full decade with this one but
it was in the last thirteen months that we thought it bubblelicious).
Here's a July 1, 2023 post:
....So, we are faced with the decision whether-or-not to play a
dangerous little game, riding the bubble knowing full well it is a
bubble, or retiring to the sidelines.
For now one of
our favorite economists with one of our favorite stories.
Here's the version hosted at MIT:
By PETER TEMIN AND HANS-JOACHIM VOTH
This
paper presents a case study of a well-informed investor in the South
Sea bubble. We argue that Hoare’s Bank, a fledgling West End London
bank, knew that a bubble was in progress and nonetheless invested in the
stock: it was profitable to “ride the bubble.” Using a unique dataset
on daily trades, we show that this sophisticated investor was not
constrained by such institutional factors as restrictions on short sales
or agency problems...
The two most important parts of the paper "II. Hoare’s Trading
Performance" and "III. Causes of Success" are definitely worth a couple
minutes....
*****
....We'll have more on the big stories, autonomous vehicles, agentic AI and humanoid robots later today.
Mr. Huang believes they are each trillion dollar+ addressable markets.
*We reiterated the ride the bubble pitch a few more times, despite some trepidation.
note: stock prices should be divided by 10 to adjust for the most recent stock split.
January 19, 2024 at $594.91 "AI: Lessons From The South Sea Bubble".
February 6, 2024:
Nvidia Collapses (gives back half yesterday's gains) plus Isaac Newton and Daniel Defoe do a drive by (NVDA)
The stock is down $11.87, so a little less than half yesterday's
up-move. $681.45 last after trading as low as $663.00 (down $30.31 and
almost the entire Monday $31.72 up-move.) Unfortunately there is a gap on the chart at $660 so it didn't completely fill. Nervous-making....
By-the-bye, that $660 ($66, new style) is the "cut in half" number.
March 6, 2024:
Earlier this morning the stock got to $889.68 and we are still pitching the "ride the bubble" approach—up $220 since the last mention, Feb. 6—but that could change anywhere between today and the end of the NVDA GTC conference (Mar. 21)....
If interested in some of our history with the big dog there are links embedded in January 2024's "Nvidia expands its reach in China’s electric vehicle sector" (NVD
Finally, as Adam Smith put it in his book on the 'sixties bull market, The Money Game:
“Now you know and I know that one day the orchestra will stop playing and the
wind will rattle through the broken window panes, and the anticipation of this
freezes us. All of these kids but one will be broke, and that one will be the multi-
millionaire, the Arthur Rock of the new generation. There is always one, and
maybe we will find him.”
—As seen in February 2024's "JPMorgan's Jamie Dimon On The Business Case For AI: "This Is Not Hype" (JPM)"
Not being in government, I don't have the authoritarian type of authority so I tend toward Burkeian humble and lovable:
"All which a man without authority can give--
His unbiased opinion, his honest advice, and his best reasons."
—Edmund Burke (1791)*
—
Power Politics For Outsiders, March 2023 (and elsewhere)
*Potential downside: Burke was described by Edward Gibbon (he of
The...Decline and Fall...) as:
"The most eloquent and rational madman that I ever knew".